Roethke and Salinas Gabriel Mourao

 

Gabriel Mourao

 

Theodore’s Papa’s Waltz is a complete contrast to Luis Omar’s My Father is a Simple Man. While one poem is about an alcoholic father that is physically abusive but loving of his son. While the other poem the is about a father that is old, calm, quiet, and passive. The contrast is clear as day, but one thing to note about the two behaviors about the two men is that they both love their sons very much. When the drunk father would,” Then waltzed me off to bed Still clinging to your shirt” (Theodore Roethke) this action of tucking his child to sleep is a way of caring. In Luis Omar’s poem you can also see the father is very caring and wants his son to be healthy, “He's sure I'll be healthy so long as I eat more oranges” (Luis Omar Salinas). There similarities show and the differences in the poem aren’t so clear as bad alcoholic dad vs good kind dad. In Theodore’s poem for example the father tucks his son to sleep and plays with him a dance. Although the son does not see it as a playful dance, we can give the father the benefit of the doubt and say that maybe through the father’s eyes he is playing with his son. Something similar can be said with Luis’s poem, the father tells his son not to fear death and to be healthy, but that advise can lead to adverse connotations. Fear is an essential part of human survival, so much so that if we lose it things that we should run away from, like a bear, catch us and at worse killing us. Although the two poems may seem like an open and shut case it may not be like that as we don’t have full context. But I digress, because I’m not saying this to justify the two father’s actions nor am I choosing a side and labeling them. I want to show others that stories aren’t so clear as day and that there is no hero and bad guy, but instead circumstances and perspectives



Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

what I learned this semester

  Its not just what I learned this semester through this class, it's the experience, the motivation, the literature, and the content I felt coming to this class every Monday and Wednesday. I learned alot through this class, first, I learned to be motivated, through Dr. Ellis’s constant uplifting and motivating comments, I actually learned to be more confident in my work and produce better papers. Through the presentations and class discussion, I was able to attend a class that had fostered such a comfortable space for students allowing us to practice our speech and discussion qualities. Through these discussions, I was able to be prepared for the next assignment due, not only that but I was able to go back home after class with a fruitful amount of new knowledge. English, reading, and writing used to be something I was genuinely afraid of but through this class, I have learned that there is more to it. Literature holds so much meaning in a student's life as we continue to study...
Read more

What I learned this semester

 This semester I learned there are multiple ways to interpret the text. Such as The Waltz, where some people interpreted the text to be about a father and his abused son. Others interpreted it as friendly interaction between father and son. These interpretations are bought on by the person's experiences and past experiences, making every analysis unique. I once thought that there was such a thing as a right and wrong analysis, now I've learned that any analysis is right as long as it can be proven. I'd say more than learning, I found this course an experience. An extremely good one. Just as thrilling as falling in love with a new song on the radio. Its thanks to my classmates but also to Dr. Ellis for enabling and hosting such a space where we can have the amazing conversations that we do. A safe space to learn and grow. The feel of a home or a small little book club of friends.  Literature can show a person's way of thinking while also expanding upon it. Literature is ...
Read more

What I've learned

  I always hated English classes in grade school, because we were always required to read books from before our time and come up with an overanalyzed response without hearing other viewpoints. Being in this class has been very different from those other courses in turn making it feel like a breath of fresh air. Being a finance major I dread most classes although I love the subject. Whenever the clock strikes 4:30 on Mondays and Wednesdays I get excited because I know there will be inciteful and respectful conversations had between myself and peers. The structure of this course makes me as a student more excited to read these books regardless how old they are, because as a class we do an excellent job of being able to relate the topics to current worldly, and community issues. Even in the earlier days of our course we were able to touch on heavy subjects such as racism, and certain slang and derogatory words, and not once did the conversations go in a direction when it needed to be ...
Read more